It feels like Harry Potter is a part of our history, our culture, the thing that tied our childhood sense of magic to a collective story. A lot of people don’t want to give it up, even if they are aware that by spending money on the IP they are funding an anti-rights campaign with real material consequences for trans people.
As a trans person I didn’t have a choice. Hogwarts was the world I dreamed of escape to when I was being bullied every day in my extremely normal English comprehensive school. A place where I’d know I belonged, simply by virtue of the fact I was there. Then its author became the bully, the person deciding that I don’t belong.
But I’ve learned that the part of me that connected with Harry Potter is so much larger than it.
There are other fantasy stories with a magical world that exists in secret alongside our own. I’m fond of Lev Grossman’s The Magicians; an adult take, where magic comes from pain and the familiar cruelties of our world bring so much of it. The works of Ursula K Leguin open up your world to immense possibilities beyond the social and biological limits that we take for granted. There’s the obvious example of Tolkien (tbh this is often via Blind Guardian for me, Nightfall in Middle Earth is better than the Silmarillion I’m sorry don’t hate me for saying it).
Whatever it is that resonates with you, know that all of it draws on something larger than any individual work, larger than any personal taste.
It’s the Arthurian Legend that yearns for something older than the Norman Conquest, for a part of something that was erased by empire, before we became imperialists. Something more powerful and true than violent conquest, more resilient than what we lost before we even became us.
You yearn for the long, unrecorded lineage of healers, seers, and knowers of the natural world, over countless generations, people who were revered and loved and people who faced violence because of their gender and because of their divergent bodyminds.
Magic is something we reach for when we are powerless. It isn’t real, but it is a story that allows us to access something within us that defies logic, a feeling stronger than thought, a will stronger than reason. If we allow our yearning for magic to be manipulated by the powerful, then we have truly lost ourselves.
This power of magic to help us imagine better worlds is very familiar to trans people, who use it widely in our own creative works. Arguably, the resurgence of Harry Potter merchandising, the receptivity to this massive marketing and PR effort, is only possible because no inclusive alternative has been given a fair chance. There are so many trans people creating new speculative fiction universes. It’s part of our culture! Steven Universe was probably the last to find mainstream support before the backlash came.
The commissioning problem in the UK media industry is so much worse for trans people - look at Jen Ives’s recent reflections on being a trans contractor at the BBC. It’s only a specific kind of well-resourced trans person who finds any success here, and even those people are held back by widespread prejudice that makes their very existence controversial. In the US, GLAAD recently reported that the number of trans characters on TV has plummeted, stating that next year’s shows will have none at all (I assume they’re excluding the social worker on The Pitt because the character’s gender history is not mentioned, though the actor is trans).
We deserve better stories than Harry Potter. We deserve a media landscape that gives magic back to the marginalised.